HW Header
"Beware MLMUG Tinkerors"

[ home | reviews | bylaws | library ]

This site has many more reviews, all written by MLMUG members.
View all our book reviews. Or, view our
Software, hardware, and game reviews
.

A Hardware Review
by David Berg

iKaraoke
Product:
iKaraoke

Manufacturer: Griffin at http://www.griffintechnology.com/.

Price: $49.95 (street price from $31 at various web stores)

System Requirements: iPod (4th generation or later, mini, nano)

Overall Rating: 3 out of 5 Apples

iKaraoke...iLikeIt

Like to sing along with your music? Now, Griffin (griffintechnology.com) has made it possible to experience "the thrill of karaoke on your iPod." The device is a really neat brushed metal microphone attached to a four foot cable ending in an iPod docking jack. Simply plug it into the dock connector on your iPod, then press a button on the mic to configure the device to play through an FM radio station or line-out to your speakers. You're set to find a song and sing along. The iKaraoke has another button to allow either the entire sound track to play or to eliminate the lead vocals — which you then supply.

The device is a cylindrical five inch microphone on a cord; the mic is about an inch taller than a full size iPod. Toward the top of the mic is a ring that lights to let you know when you are in a settings mode. Setting up iKaraoke is simple: plug the jack into the dock connector of your iPod and turn on the iPod. Pressing and holding one button shows the setup menu on your iPod screen. The settings permit you to determine whether the output mode is an FM transmission or line-out; the dock connecter end has a line out jack built in to it for easy connection to speakers or a sound system. The other settings permit you to set a reverb level, music or PA level, and the FM frequency for transmission mode. Changing settings is no more difficult than a press-and-hold of one button to enter a mode, then pressing another button to make changes. All of this is clearly visible on the iPod screen.

Once the settings are completed (no more than a minute at most), then choose your playlist, music, or song. Start the music using the iPod controls as usual. There are three buttons on one side of the mic that permit you to play/pause, skip tracks both forward and backward, and to scan within a track if held. Essentially, you control the iPod via the microphone. Turn the mic 180 degrees to find the vocals switch which permits you to damp down but not completely eliminate the lead vocals. That is, once you have chosen your song, play it, engage the vocal switch and sing along karaoke style. The idea is to give you that special feel for that you would achieve using a larger machine or perhaps making a fool of yourself in a bar. A push on the switch in the other direction brings the full volume of vocals and background music back again.

So how does iKaraoke perform in practice? Well it's certainly fun but a bit flawed! First, imagine that you have connected your iPod to a set of speakers or stereo system through the line out connection of the iKaraoke jack. Set it up to play in this mode, turn on your speakers, choose your song, and belt it out. Actually on some songs, the entire lead vocal is eliminated leaving you to do a complete solo. Yet on other songs, the music and vocals just sound damped like you are wearing ear plugs; yes you can sing to it but the experience isn't great. The manual states, "Note that the effects of the Vocal Switch can vary from track to track, depending on how the music was recorded." I went through several dozen songs and couldn't find a pattern of what worked best — perhaps more trial and error is necessary. If you have karaoke tracks on your iPod already, then this is not an issue at all. Next, I reset the iKaraoke controls for FM transmission and to a frequency that I know works well in my house and car. I played and sang through the home stereo receiver and thankfully the neighbors did not call the cops or SPCA. Next out to the car: the device did play through the car radio for my sing-a-long just as it did in the home. Performance was the same as in the line-out mode except as with any FM transmitter and iPod, you suffer static, hum, and occasional loss of signal.

How would you use iKaraoke? Vanity first: you can sing sing sing and win your Grammy or American Idol championship sans Simon the critic. On a long trip, with a car load of kids, you would probably run yourself off the road; but you'll all roll merrily along. At a party, you can set it up to play your children's music, Macarena, chicken dance or hava nagila. At Christmas, all of your favorite carols can play through your speakers as you pass around the microphone. An added bonus: in PA mode, it will allow you to address the crowd through your speakers in both line-out and FM mode.

Would I buy one? Yes I would! I checked the street prices on the Internet and found the device as low as $30. It would be both a fun and unique gift as well.

MarkB

Reviewer: David Berg

David Berg is a college professor and psychologist. He has been a Mac user since 1937 and a member of MLMUG since 1975.

You can join him at PPUG meetings, where he feels right at home at the Manayunk Brewery in Manayunk, PA.

This site has many more reviews, all written by MLMUG members.
View all our book reviews. Or, view our
Software, hardware, and game reviews
.

[ home | newsletter | past join | listserve shareware | directory links | md9 | ]

© 2007 by David Berg & MLMUG
Posted 03/20/07
Updated 03/21/07