MLMUG Book Review
MLMUGers subject their Macs to mysterious code

[ home | reviews | bylaws | library ]

This site has many more reviews, all written by MLMUG members.
View all our book reviews. Or, view our
Software, hardware, and game reviews
.

A Software Review
by Mike Berman

FirstEdge Title: MYOB FirstEdge —
v 1.0, release 5.7.2


Publisher: MYOB Limited
Media: Software
Level: Basic Small Business, such as a Mom & Pop, Small Professional Practice, Artist or Photographer, Club or Association, Tech Consultant, etc.
List Price: $99.99

I have used Macs exclusively since 1987 when I got my first computer, a Mac Plus. Their primary task was aiding in writing reports and keeping cash accounts for my home inspection business until I retired at the end of '02. From then on, my Power Mac DP 450, running Photohop Elements in OS 9.1, has served me well in my photography hobby/profession.

Since I have never done any true accounting, it took a few tries to get the hang of MYOB FirstEdge. My one-man business—except for end-of-year tax prep done by my accountant—was adequately served by cash bookkeeping entries in Quicken.

The software is neatly and attractively packaged in the expected slick box with listings and screen shots of some of its basic features — enough to allow one to know whether the program will fit one's needs. It comes with a Getting Started Guide, full, easy to follow printed (160 pages) and PDF manuals, and browser Help ("Learning Center") files installed with the app and Web-based. The single CD ROM also includes QuickTime 5. This app will run on a Power Mac in OS 8.6, 9.x, and OS X. I ran it in OS 9.1.

My long experience in using Quicken was of little help in learning and using this application. It is based on the double-entry system of accounting. The manuals explain this, including the concept of "T" accounts. (I now finally understand the old Accounting 101 joke about "debit on the window side".) Data can be imported from Quicken and from several tab- or comma-delimited sources.

With FirstEdge, one can track sales, expenses, customers, and cash, as well as accounts receivable and payable, inventory, cost-of-sales, vendors, credit card transactions, taxes, and dozens more. It can be set up to figure and add sales tax to transactions.

For my test run, I set up a mock "company file" for my photographic endeavour. My "customer" list included venues where I have displayed and/or sold my work, including several galleries and open-air art festivals, and a house portrait "job" that I did several months ago. Initial setup requires that all these, plus inventory (I entered several of my photo titles and prices), suppliers, assets, etc., be listed on "cards." This was a rather tedious procedure, but once done, is easily maintained and updated. Inventory cards can be customized with illustrations of the items. I handily imported thumbnail copies of my photographs to inventory cards.

The big advantage of using this type of program is that at any time, one can summon up reports on the state of the business: balance sheets, P & L statements, accounts payable and receivable, expense and income pictures, tax liabilities—about 50 altogether. It can be used to generate invoices, print checks and other forms in several styles, track petty cash expenditures, prepare bank deposits. In the (hopefully rare) event of a bounced check, the sales transaction can be reversed, and the customer billed for the bank fee. In such cases, the application's preferences must be set to disallow transaction changes; they must be reversed.

This program will not handle payroll, time billing, or other advanced business functions. For these, the more comprehensive—and expensive—MYOB AccountEdge is recommended.

Another nifty feature is FirstEdge's ability to import banking and credit card statements from your financial institutions' websites. These can be used in the reconciliation processes, or to match transactions in your on-line accounts with items in your FirstEdge account. The process was simple: Go into your bank account's website, export the chosen date range to a QIF, QFX, or OFC file, and open that file with the "Get Statement" command in FirstEdge.

One of the most difficult things for me to master was learning which keys not to hit while working in FirstEdge. Under certain conditions, hitting a directional arrow or the escape key, rather than stopping or reversing an operational step, caused the entire operation to completely vaporize, necessitating starting it over from scratch. Made me feel like I was back in '87, learning to use my Mac Plus for the first time.

Mike Berman

There is a lot to learn in MYOB FirstEdge, and in my opinion, a good bit of its interface is less-than-intuitive and non-Mac-like. For me, the program had a rather steep learning curve, but it is powerful for its size and price. Unless you are running a highly complex business, this program should be more than adequate for your needs.

Reviewer: Mike Berman

This site has many more reviews, all written by MLMUG members.
View all our book reviews. Or, view our
Software, hardware, and game reviews
.

[ home | newsletter | past | join | listserve | shareware | directory | links | md9 ]

© 2004 by Mike Berman & MLMUG
Posted 05/22/04
Updated 09/15/04