MLMUG Book Review
MLMUGers subject their Macs to mysterious code

[ home | reviews | bylaws | library ]

This site has many more reviews, all written by MLMUG members.
View all our book reviews. Or, view our
Software, hardware, and game reviews
.

Software Review
by Mark C. Stringfellow, Maximum Computer Systems, Inc.
Apple Consultant Network Member and Cross Platform Consultant

MacDrive5Box Title: MacDrive 5 for Windows

By Mediafour Corporation
$19.95

I work with both Macs and PCs on many local area networks. I share both Mac and PC files in my office and with clients at their offices. Sometimes it is necessary to connect a MacOS formatted drive to a PC and keep working. Most of the time the connection is through the network. Sometimes the MacOS media is directly connected to a PC. MacDrive 5 for Windows allows me to use any hard drive, floppy or other media formatted in MacOS HFS or HFS+ on most any PC.

About MacDrive 5
Many popular software packages exist in versions for both Windows and Mac OS, and are so similar in design and function that they are file-compatible. For example, a file created by Microsoft Excel for Macintosh can also be understood by Microsoft Excel for Windows. Even when using such �cross-platform� compatible software, a major and long-standing problem has been the lack of a straightforward way to transfer files between computers of different types. Mac and PC disks cannot normally be shared between the two types of computers, as each stores the documents you create on disks in different and incompatible ways. Normally, a disk formatted on one platform will not be recognized by the other. Modern Mac systems do include software that allows them to understand PC disks, but the results are not always desirable, and this does nothing to address the problems experienced by Windows users needing files from Mac disks. MacDrive addresses this problem in a very straightforward manner: it gives the Windows desktop, Explorer and any software running under Windows the ability to freely open and save files on Macintosh disks.

With MacDrive, when you wish to use a Mac disk, you don�t need to run any software� to open or save files on a Mac format disk, you can just put it in and use it immediately. MacDrive can share all types of files between Macintosh and Windows, but it does not interpret or modify files. This means that you can share all types of files on Mac disks, but you need to have both Windows and Mac OS software that can understand the files you use.

MacDrive provides user-modifiable behaviors so that files created under Mac OS appear with appropriate file name extensions under Windows, and files created on Mac disks under Windows appear with appropriate icons under Mac OS.

You can even format Mac disks, copy Mac disks, and both create and decode MacBinary files with convenient shortcut menu options.

MacDrive opens a world of data-sharing possibilities:

- Save your Windows spreadsheet to a colleague�s Mac floppy in the middle of a cross-country flight.

- Mac format a Zip disk and copy your publishing files to it before sending it off to the service bureau that is frequently confused by PC-formatted cartridges.

- Configure your 3D animation software to render directly to a Mac format Jaz cartridge, then transfer a gigabyte of data between Windows and Mac OS in only the time it takes to move the cartridge.

- Insert clip art from a Mac CD-ROM directly into Microsoft Word.

System Requirements
System requirements are modest. MacDrive requires Windows Me, 98, 95, NT 4.0, 2000 or XP, and works with most types of disks. There are no special software or hardware requirements, although an appropriate adapter (USB, SCSI, FireWire, etc.) is required if you intend to share external drives between Windows and Mac OS by unplugging the drives from one computer and into the other.

Using MacDrive Immediately
To start using Mac-formatted disks right away, do this:

- Install MacDrive 5

- Put a Mac disk in any drive

- Access the drive from the desktop, Explorer or your favorite software

Media Compatibility
MacDrive enables the Windows desktop, Explorer and other software running under Windows to access nearly any type of Mac disk. Windows, however, must be able to communicate with the drive to allow MacDrive to function.

If you are currently able to use your removable media drive with normal PC-formatted (MS-DOS) cartridges, you can be confident that Windows is successfully communicating with the drive, and that MacDrive will be able to recognize Mac disks when they are inserted.

If the disk device is new to your Windows system (as would be the case, for example, when plugging an external SCSI drive from a Mac OS system into your Windows PC�s SCSI adapter for the first time), it is likely that it will be recognized by Windows and work properly without requiring the installation of driver software from the drive or adapter manufacturer, but this is not guaranteed.

When attaching a removable media drive, if Windows presents no drive letter for the removable drive, the hardware may not be properly installed, or driver software may be necessary. When attaching a Mac external hard drive, Windows will not present a drive letter unless both the drive and MacDrive are properly installed. In either case, watch for notification from your SCSI, USB, FireWire, Fibre Channel or other adapter during the boot process detailing detected drives. If a newly attached SCSI drive is not detected, check for ID conflicts and proper termination. Regardless of the drive type, if it is not detected, look for faulty cables, check both drive and adapter configuration, and try PC-formatted disks in order to confirm whether the drive is fundamentally working.

MacDrive works with high-density floppies, Zip, Jaz, SyQuest, optical, ORB, MO, CD-ROM, hard drives and nearly any other disk device that works with Windows.

High-density (1.44MB) Mac floppies can be accessed on any Windows system with a 31/2" floppy drive. Low-density (400KB and 800KB) Mac floppies cannot be accessed due to physical differences between the floppy drives in Mac OS systems and Windows PCs.

Software Compatibility
MacDrive makes Mac disks appear and behave almost exactly like standard PC-formatted disks.

So-called �classic� versions of the Mac OS support file names up to 31 characters in length, and Mac OS X supports file names up to 255 characters in length. Because Windows supports file names of these lengths, there is rarely a need to shorten a Mac file name for compatibility�s sake. MacDrive does occasionally have to present slightly altered filenames, however, as the Mac allows file names containing characters that are forbidden by Windows. In these cases, MacDrive substitutes characters as necessary to bring the displayed file name into compliance with Windows file naming rules.

MacDrive is a wonderful addition to any network that supports both Mac and PC computers. The ability to plug a MacOS formatted disk into a PC and know it will work is very productive. While network sharing between MacOS X and PC computers is easy, there are times when it is nice to just plug a Mac drive into a PC Firewire or USB port without reformatting the drive. MacDrive plays so well with Macintosh you will wonder why you still don�t own this great software.

MCS Logo MCS Logo MCS Logo MCS Logo MCS Logo
MacDrive 5 Rates 5 out of 5 MCS Logos!
MarkString
— Mark C. Stringfellow
MLMUG Reviewer

This site has many more reviews, all written by MLMUG members.
View all our book reviews. Or, view our
Software, hardware, and game reviews
.

[ home | newsletter | past | join | listserve | shareware | directory | links | md9 ]

© 2004 by Mark C. Stringfellow & MLMUG

Posted 05/05/04
Updated 08/23/04