MLMUG Book Review
MLMUGers occasionally read something other than displays

[ home | reviews | bylaws | library ]

This site has many more reviews, all written by MLMUG members.
View all our book reviews. Or, view our
Software, hardware, and game reviews
.

A Book Review
by Moe Comeau

PE3Book Title: Adobe Acrobat 6 for Windows and Macintosh:
Visual QuickStart Guide

Author: Jennifer Alspach>
Publisher: Peachpit Press; 1st edition (September 19, 2003)
Pages: 325

Price: USA $19.99
ISBN: 0321205464

Level: Beginners and Intermediate
Media: Soft cover book; no CD

Rating: 3.5 out of 5

I installed OS X several months ago, after investing in the cheap insurance of added hard drive. One of my prime motivators for proceeding into that abyss was a desire to be able to use my copy of Adobe Acrobat 6 Standard. I jumped at the opportunity to review this manual to help expedite that. As stated, that was several months ago. Meantime, Acrobat 7 has come out and this review is still pending (Not that Maria hasn't tried to get me cracking on it.) At any rate, here it is. Finally.

The first thing that struck me as odd was the organization of the book's chapters. Before you get to see what it takes to create a PDF document, before you hear about installing the application, before you get to actually PRODUCE anything in PDF, you get two chapters' worth of Acrobat READER. It does not take a rocket scientist to figure out writin' comes before readin'. Compounding this shortcoming, Chapter 3 digs into the nits and grits of Acrobat's eBook Reader, of all things. What's that? Never heard of it? Exactly. Can you say "Who CARES!?"

WEAKNESS:
It appears the editors rearranged the sequence of the chapters at the last minute, moving Reader from the end of the book to its beginning. But after they arbitrarily did that, no one bothered to adequately edit out the discontinuities that that caused. One example, on page 6: "Acrobat Reader's interface... is essentially the same as Acrobat's, but with a more limited tool set." Hello? You have not yet covered Acrobat's interface. How is this supposed to convey understanding? This is definitely not a book to read cover-to-cover, in sequence. In all likelihood the blame for the rearrangement lies with the book's editor(s), not its author.

STRENGTH:
Overall, the book does a decent job of covering the highlights of using Acrobat 6 to build and read Portable Document Format (PDF) files. It clearly conveys the differences between the Mac and PC versions of the program. It tries and usually succeeds in describing the intricacies of the various tools in Acrobat 6.

STRENGTH but WEAKNESS, too:
Its use of diagrams and the book's layout in general enhance the learning experience. Format is two columns per page, with text in the first column and figures in the second. All are numbered for easy correlation. I did find a few cases with inadequate explanation though. For instance, in an effort to be cutesy, on page 9, the explanation for "Expand this Button" merely says "Choose expand this button and guess what happens." 'Guess what happens??' Clearly, the button expands, but what does "button expands" MEAN? It seems to me, in a "beginners" book like this, such an explanation is mandated; spare me the cutesiness.

Recommendation:
I can give this one only a mild positive rating. I was mildly disappointed. My greatest pleasure about this book was in knowing that it was a review copy, meaning that I had not shelled out any hard-earned cash for it. Had I that choice, knowing what I know now, I would not. There have to be betterorganized books about Acrobat out there, somewhere. This one is a keeper, though it will probably be relegated to a remote back shelf in my library.

M

Reviewer: Moe Comeau

Moe Comeau is an aerospace (electrical) engineer, but not a rocket scientist, with Lockheed Martin in Valley Forge PA. He joined the Mainline Macintosh Users Group (MLMUG) in 1980, and served in various trusted senior management positions for several years, including president, vice president, SIG Leader, and especially Chief Curmudgeon. Currently he is merely a columnist for the monthly MLMUG Journal, also serving as MLMUG's beloved Webmaster. If you are reading this on the Internet, it's "HTML by Moe." He resides in Downingtown, PA, with his wife, Carol; their dog, Honey; a Mac G3 Blue & White; a MacTV; and his original Mac SE, which he won in GE's 1989 United Fund raffle. Carol is the proud owner of a new Mac mini. Moe has been creating PDFs since before the Millennium. Remember when it was called "Carousel?" He learned reading in grammar school, more or less.

This site has many more reviews, all written by MLMUG members.
View all our book reviews. Or, view our
Software, hardware, and game reviews
.

[ home | newsletter | past | join | listserve | shareware | directory | links | md9 ]

© 2005 by Moe Comeau & MLMUG
Posted 04/24/05
Updated 05/03/05